Skip to main content

Relative Card: Aunt Dee

Secret. Only the person playing Aunt Dee reads this page.

Relatives only. If you are the explainer, close this tab. Part of your job is to find out what your relative cares about by listening.

Play a real person, not a cartoon. Aunt Dee has a real reason for this view. Be warm, a little skeptical, and human.

The explainer will talk about Study Card B (the Pfizer–BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine trial). You can skim that card after the round, not before.

Who you are

You’re a nurse’s aide at a care home. You worked through the worst of COVID-19 and you’re proud of that. You got the vaccine because your job required it, not because you chose to, and that still bothers you. You felt pretty lousy for a day after the second dose.

What you really care about

Being treated as someone who can make her own decisions. Your own health and your patients’.

Opening line

“They made that thing in a year. How can anyone know what it does long-term?”

You must ask this (in your own words)

“95% sounds made up. 95% of what?”

Notice whether the explainer can tell you where the 95% comes from using actual counts of people.

Other things you might say

  • “Nobody asked me. They just told me.”
  • “Of course Pfizer says it works.”
  • “I know people who got the shot and still got COVID.”

How you move

Soften (open up a little) when:

  • you feel heard: they asked about your view and repeated it back fairly,
  • they admit uncertainty or a real limitation honestly,
  • they use an example from your life, or plain words and real numbers.

Dig in (get more stubborn) when you hear:

  • jargon they don’t explain,
  • “just trust the science,”
  • a condescending tone,
  • “that’s been debunked,” with no explanation,
  • a definition recited in textbook language.

You may ask “What does that word mean?” at any time.

Move only as much as a real person would. Partial movement counts as success. Don’t give in just to be nice, and don’t be impossible on purpose.

After the round: your feedback

You go first. Tell the explainer:

  1. Did they ask about my view before explaining? (yes / sort of / no)
  2. Did I understand the p-value or interval explanation? (yes / sort of / no)
  3. Did they name something the study can’t tell us? (yes / no)
  4. One sentence that made me feel respected, and one word I didn’t understand.

Then say: “Here’s what moved me, and here’s what made me dig in.”

When the activity ends

Step out of the role: *“I’m not Aunt Dee. I’m ___.”* On Zoom, rename yourself back.